DeWalt vs Makita for Impact Wrench - Which One to Get?

Hey all, I'm in the market for a new cordless impact wrench for some automotive work. I've narrowed it down to DeWalt or Makita. I do a lot of DIY stuff around the house, but I also help out at my buddy's garage occasionally. I need something that can handle lug nuts and suspension bolts without breaking a sweat. What's your take? I've heard good things about both brands, but I'm leaning toward DeWalt because I already have some batteries. But I'm open to switching if Makita is clearly better.

Hey Will! I've used both in my line of work. For automotive, I'd say Makita has the edge in terms of torque and battery life. Their XWT08 has like 780 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque, which is insane. DeWalt's is no slouch either, but I've seen Makita handle some rusted bolts that DeWalt struggled with. Also, Makita batteries seem to hold up well under heavy use. But since you already have DeWalt batteries, that's a big factor. Maybe just get the bare tool? Check the torque specs on the model you're considering. If it's above 700, it should be fine.

Just a safety tip: whatever you get, make sure you use the right impact sockets and eye protection. I've seen bolts snap and bits fly. Also, when using an impact wrench, always brace yourself – the torque can twist your wrist if you're not ready. I've done this for years, and it's no joke. As for brand, I'm a Makita fan, but DeWalt makes solid stuff too. If you can afford it, get the Makita for the higher torque, but don't overlook the possibility of getting an adapter for your batteries. They exist, but they can be unreliable. Just something to think about.

Thanks for the input! I was actually thinking of the DCF900 from DeWalt, which has like 700 ft-lbs. But if Makita has more, maybe I should switch. My only issue is I've invested in a few DeWalt batteries already. That adapter idea is sketchy though. I might just grab the DeWalt and see how it goes. If it's not enough, I'll make the jump later. Appreciate the safety tips, Rick848 – I'll keep that in mind.

Will, the DCF900 is a beast too. Honestly, unless you're working on heavy trucks or tractors, 700 ft-lbs is plenty for most cars. I've used both, and they both will zip off lug nuts without a problem. I think you'll be happy with the DeWalt, especially since you already have batteries. And remember, you can always sell the batteries if you decide to switch later. But I'd say stick with what you have – you won't regret the DeWalt.